art

The Sleep Of Reason Produces Monsters


4 Comments

“Sometimes even to live is an act of courage.” 
― Lucius Annaeus Seneca

Have you ever said to yourself: ‘damn, this really is a shitty day’? I have, even months or years can go about that way. So, what to do about it?

Let me introduce you to one of the greatest Spanish 19th-century painters, Francisco Goya. Goya was the royal painter of several kings and other members of the nobility at the time, as well as independent an artist. He painted “La Duquesa de Alba” on the left, said to be the most beautiful woman of all Spain, and a widow, but that’s another story. Today his paintings are humanity’s heritage, and if you are interested in his work, you can find it at “El Museo del Prado” in Madrid, Spain.

Like many artists from the time, Goya was greatly influenced by the enlightenment and its values of progress and liberalism. Goya is a particular and unusual artist, the evolution of his life-work shows what happens when these values are shunned by society and give way instead of ignorance and madness.

The work of Goya begins with “The Tapestries” which adorned the streets and the palaces of Spain, inspired in the Rococo style. A style that is light, playful and elegant such as the one on the left. The paintings show the daily lives of peasants and nobility.

Charles IV and his family

He then became the painter of the court of Charles IV. A disappointing autocrat monarch in comparison to his father Charles III, who enacted reforms that brought secular and enlightened values to Spain.

In 1793, Goya contracted an unknown illness that left him deaf. Although he still accepted commissions from his royal clientele, the disease was a dark turning point for his career. His work started deviating into grimmer and darker paintings shockingly different from “The Tapestries” such as the “Yard with Lunatics” below.

Yard with lunatics

Goya began to see the country around him with grim clarity. He saw the Spanish culture as tragic and comic at the same time. The whole country was backsliding from the road to modernity into superstition and ignorance. People were too stupid and ignorant to know what they need. Around this time he painted “Los Caprichos” (“The Caprices”).

His way of thinking was all summed up in the painting “The sleep of reason produces monsters.”

The Sleep of Reason Produces Monsters

In this picture, Goya shows what happens when you let ignorance and corruption lose Monsters start lurking in your head, you can no longer distinguish right from wrong, you are lurking in the dark.

During the following years, Napoleon conquered Spain and brutally massacred everyone that opposed him. Goya witnessed the bloodshed first-hand and it affected him deeply. The most impacting painting he did during the time was “The Third of May 1808”. The painting can be described as honest as it shows, in comparison to contemporary war paintings, that show war as composed and heroic, the horrors of war, the fear, the brutality.

Ferdinand VII

It was going to be 5 years until Spain regained the throne from France. In the interim of the war, resistors from Spain developed the Constitution of 1812, which called for liberal reforms such as national sovereignty, freedom of the press and free enterprise. But the new king, whom Goya painted as well, Ferdinand VII, gained power and abolished the constitution and arrested those who made it, I know, hard not to love him.

Late in his life, Goya bought, ironically, “La Quinta del Sordo”(“The Villa of the Deaf.”) in which he withdrew, disheartened. The country which in his youth reached for principles of enlightenment and modernity, was being now swallowed again by autocracy. Scared by war, scared by illness and madness.

It was around this time when Goya began to paint his most famous artwork, “The Black Paintings.” He painted nightmarish paintings directly unto the walls of his house. One of the paintings, the most desolate and horrifying in my opinion is: “Saturn Devouring His Son.”

The black painting shows Saturn eating one of his sons in the most gruesome manner. You can see the despair in his face, it feels as if he knows that with what he is about to do, although being a god, is going to be exempt from any redemption and from ever forgiving himself. He is lost in the thirst for eternal power and madness and he knows that there is no turning back. If you could paint the abstract terms of despair, sadness, and loss, this painting does it all. Can you imagine having your morning coffee while this monster looks back at you?

You have to take into account that the black paintings were discovered long after Goya’s death. Goya didn’t paint them for anyone but himself. So the question naturally arises, why?

Maybe he was just trying to be honest about the dark side of human nature, at least what he saw at the time, maybe he wanted to exorcise his demons. But what’s terrifying about the paintings is that, we simply don’t know, the paintings are, truly, beyond interpretation.

So, I have to ask, how do you feel about your shitty day now? There are definitely degrees of shittiness, aren’t they?

OK, sorry for the grim picture I just gave you. But I wanted you to see what happens when all hope is abandoned and reality is just to terrible to bear.

Today, Goya’s paintings show how utterly terrible and horrifying is the loss of reason, and I might add the loss of virtue.

I greatly admire Goya for what he did. He went into places of the mind were no light shines anymore, places were there is just death and despair, and he painted them. By painting what he painted and by putting his discomfort and silent protest out there, today, we can look back upon his art to know what the sleep of reason really entails, especially in our times, were reason seems to be fading away to give way to numbing entertainment, putting us slowly back to sleep.

The sleep of reason produces monsters.

What Can You Learn About Goya?

Don’t let yourself fall asleep.

But not everyone is a Cato and not doing so is damn hard many times, just ask Goya. One thing is to have a shitty day, another is to see your country falling back into superstition and ignorance, feeling the impotence of not being able to do anything.

I wanted to write about Goya to convey what a Stoic practice really implies. It’s easy to practice stoicism when everything is going good and life challenges are easy, but true stoic practice begins when it’s damn hard. That’s the time when life really puts you to the test. Illness, falling deaf, war, autocracy, all of these things weren’t under Goya’s control, all that was was his reaction towards it, and his reaction was to paint the grimmest paintings in art’s history that can hardly be compared to anything else. Goya achieved the goal of every artist: to express something in such a way that it’s impossible not to stop and reflect on what the artist wants to say and inspire action.

The practice of virtue and reason sets you free, but one thing is reading about it and feeling good about the possibility of freedom and an entirely different thing is to actually practice it.

Fortunately, very few of us have to withstand such dire circumstances on our lives but nevertheless, it’s essential to know what lies at the other end.

Lastly, I want to finish by showing you this painting by Jacques-Louis David: “The Death of Socrates.”

In this painting, Socrates, just like Seneca, bravely stands in the face of death, even after being given the option of exile, and willingly kills himself by drinking the venom to show that reason and virtue, triumphs over everything.

A great complement to this read: Separation of tasks

Subscribe and receive for free the Askesis ebook to further develop your practice of stoicism.

Subscribe here

Don’t forget to visit our shop, carefully curated. Shop

Visit our Patreon page for more stoic, Patreon only content. Thanks.

Advertisements
Conquering Fears, Psychology

Of Progress


No Comments

Now, if virtue promises happiness, prosperity, and peace, then progress in virtue is certainly progress in each of these. For to whatever point the perfection of anything absolutely brings us, progress is always an approach towards it.  Epictetus

No matter how much you read Stoic Answers or The Daily Stoic or Brain Pickings, you will never, ever have true progress unless you actually put what you read into practice. Regarding this point, Epictetus says: As if I should say to a wrestler, Show me your muscle; and he should answer me, ” See my dumb-bells.” Your dumb-bells are your own affair; I desire to see the effect of them.

What are all your books and reading good for, if you cannot see nor harvest the effect of them (happiness, peace, prosperity)?

Well, it is just so obvious isn’t it? And yet, do you really believe that you are advancing in virtue? Do you feel more happy, more at peace and more prosperous each day that passes? If so, then you don’t need my congratulations, you are on your way, you’ve won, but if not, I believe there is something in your life that is lacking in order to actually make progress and that is simply, focus.

It is no secret that the capacity to sustain attention, to focus, is at an all-time low in our society, or rather, misdirected, almost as if it is not under our control. At this point in your reading, I have to ask, have you only been reading or have you checked your phone already?

In order to get better at something, you need to pay attention to what you want to get better at, there is no other way around. With virtue, it gets a little tricky, as virtue is not something you can set a Pomodoro timer to practice for 25 minutes and get better once you are done with it, no, virtue requires you to practice 24/7 as virtue is the practice of living well and you are living all the time. There is no rest when it comes to living a virtuous life.

I’m going to let Epictetus remind us what a virtuous life is.

“There is only one way to happiness and that is to cease worrying about things which are beyond the power or our will. ” 
― Epictetus

To live a virtuous life, a happy, simple, and free life, you have to disregard, or, better said, be unaffected by that which is not under your control and at the same time regain your power to control that ,which, do is under your control.

Distraction

It is simple, but we are, however, extremely distracted. And most of the things that distract us are constantly trying to remind us about all of our desires, desires that are not needed or even wanted sometimes. We are being constantly bombarded with advertisement either from business or from our friends that show a never ending stream of food, sex or the joys of traveling, open Instagram and see for yourself.

While we are busy desiring all of these spoils that we really don’t need and really cannot control, just influence, we are deprive ourselves of the capacity to focus on what we can actually control right at the moment. Which is basically being content with what we do have in each moment and finding enjoyment in what we are doing right now. Not living in a fantasy world that has not yet come to pass.

Besides, if you want a great body or you want to go to the Great Wall of China and take a picture there, isn’t it better to focus on working or developing a plan to actually get there yourself? On top of that, what will happen if you finally get to the place which you thought was going to provide you with happiness and you suddenly realize that you cannot really enjoy it, for you did not wanted to see the place in itself but just yourself portrayed in a picture you can show of?

That is a scary thought isn’t it? The difference between enjoying The Great wall and enjoying the picture you take yourself in it is that you are free to enjoy whichever place you want, you are free to admire it and wonder in it, no matter where you are. Whereas taking a picture for validation restrains you of the enjoyment you could’ve supplied for yourself and willingly transfers it to the judgement of other people that I’m quite sure, doesn’t even care that much.

Remember this be careful to give your power away to the desires that lure you into a cycle of want that will never end, for as soon as we get something, we will want something else, and then something else, and so on.

Consuming information and being entertained is not inherently bad, of course. Enjoying a movie or watching a funny video on YouTube from time to time is not as said before, inherently wrong. What is bad is that everything that distracts you from practicing virtue, and being in control is going to affect your life experience directly, and not in a good way.

Knowing this, it is important to control our focus. As psychologist Mihaly Csikszentmihaly puts it: “Control of consciousness determines the quality of life.”

Your focus is, undoubtedly, your most important asset, this is why everyone wants it, and millions of dollars are being paid every single day for it. Wherever your focus goes, you will grow in that specific area, be it for good or for bad. If your focus is placed for the most time in the modern spoils like the ones just mentioned, then your capacity to restrict desire and focus on the positive things that are available to you will be severely restricted.

What To Do About It Then?

Well, knowing this, it is important for you to ask yourself:

  • Where is my focus most of the time?
  • What am I thinking most of the time?
  • Where do I spend most of my free time

Taking a walk or watching Instagram? Scrolling endlessly on YouTube or on a Netflix marathon? Or maybe doing some kind of sport, a good run? Even having a glass of wine or coffee with someone?

The difference between doing something easy in comparison with doing something a bit more complicated is that you need to enforce and actively practice your focus, you need to force yourself to use your attention.

This is how progress is made, by actually putting it into practice.

“First say to yourself what you would be;
and then do what you have to do.”
― Epictetus

Meditation

There is a good reason why Marcus Aurelius’s book is called Meditations. To meditate is to actively practice or reflect on something. It is basically focusing attention on something that you consciously want to be improved. In mindful meditation, for example, you force yourself to focus on your breathing. This practice might not be stoic in essence, but it lets everyone that practice it, experience first hand what focus truly is and how little we possess of it.

Sit down for 5 minutes and try to sustain your focus only on your breath. You will soon realize that thoughts come and go in your head like clouds passing through the sky. It’s hard to concentrate on your breathing entirely for more than even a few seconds. This is why meditation can greatly enhance your capacity to focus at will. If there is an actual practice to gain more control over your head, this is it.

Conscious Experience Direction

Another great way to gain control is the ability to practice values such as courage or gratitude at will.

Although you might think that gratitude is a something external, in reality it is something that can be experienced entirely at will as the only thing you need is to direct your focus towards gratefulness or courage. You can be at any moment more courageous. This tends to change perspective in funny ways. When you are living, day to day, normal life, the default mode of your thoughts will almost always inevitably tend to spiral towards the negative. It really does take effort to direct your focus on what is more useful as for example gratitude.

What happens when you are grateful? Your focus is directed towards the things that you feel happy about having in your life, maybe the very fact that you are alive wondering about your life is a reason to be grateful. In consequence, you become motivated by them and you actively search for more life instead of shunning it.

Wouldn’t you want more of that? Moment to moment, you can cultivate gratefulness as you can cultivate courage or temperance, and the Stoic values in general.

Better from worse

Lastly. It is hard to always know what you need to do or where you need to direct your attention. One quick fix that you can use as a North Star is to ask yourself: Is this better, or worse?

This question is not hard to respond to, and you will generally know what is better from worse and from that point, act accordingly.

I would like to leave you with a quote from Epictetus so you can cement in your head what’s just been said.

“How long are you going to wait before you demand the best for yourself and in no instance bypass the discriminations of reason? You have been given the principles that you ought to endorse, and you have endorsed them. What kind of teacher, then, are you still waiting for in order to refer your self-improvement to him? You are no longer a boy, but a full-grown man. If you are careless and lazy now and keep putting things off and always deferring the day after which you will attend to yourself, you will not notice that you are making no progress, but you will live and die as someone quite ordinary.
From now on, then, resolve to live as a grown-up who is making progress, and make whatever you think best a law that you never set aside. And whenever you encounter anything that is difficult or pleasurable, or highly or lowly regarded, remember that the contest is now: you are at the Olympic Games, you cannot wait any longer, and that your progress is wrecked or preserved by a single day and a single event. That is how Socrates fulfilled himself by attending to nothing except reason in everything he encountered. And you, although you are not yet a Socrates, should live as someone who at least wants to be a Socrates.” 
― Epictetus

A great complement to this read: Where Are You Putting Your Attention?

Subscribe and receive for free the Askesis ebook to further develop your practice of stoicism.

Subscribe here

NEWS

As you can see I’ve eliminated ADS from Stoic Answers. I did this to better your experience as my purpose is to enlighten and make everyone life better through Stoic Philosophy not bombard you with more manure, we have enough. Stoic Answers is now running under full support of our Patrons. Thanks a lot!

If you are interested in becoming one and supporting Stoic Answers as long as getting special benefits you can become a Patron here.

Thanks for the support. Keep strong.